- What does Verified mean?
- The citation's identifier (if present) resolves to a real scholarly record, the title substantially agrees, no field critically contradicts the record, and the citation carried enough detail — typically title plus authors — to corroborate the match. Verified is deliberately difficult to earn: when evidence is ambiguous, you get Needs review instead.
- Does Verified mean the source is credible?
- No. Verified means the bibliographic information corresponds to a real record. The paper could still be weak, superseded, corrected, retracted, or irrelevant to the claim it supports. Verification checks the record; human review checks the meaning.
- Why did CitationCheck return Needs review?
- Usually one of three reasons: the citation conflicts with the record it points to (for example, a real DOI and title with different authors — a common pattern in corrupted or generated citations); the citation is too sparse to corroborate a match (a bare DOI or a title alone); or a data provider was unavailable, so coverage was incomplete. The card always states which.
- Does Not found mean the citation is fake?
- No. Not found means the enabled sources returned no adequate record. Coverage gaps, unusual spelling, indexing delays, non-scholarly sources (newspapers, webpages, reports), and incomplete details can all cause a real work to go unfound. Treat it as a prompt to check the original source.